Doctoral defence: Kaarin Hein “The hissing behaviour of great tit (Parus major) females reflects behavioural phenotype and breeding success in a wild population”

On 13 December at 10:15 Kaarin Hein will defend her doctoral thesis “The hissing behaviour of great tit (Parus major) females reflects behavioural phenotype and breeding success in a wild population” for obtaining the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (in Animal Ecology).

Supervisor:
Associate Professor Vallo Tilgar, University of Tartu

Opponent:
Professor John Leo Quinn, University College Cork (Ireland)

Summary
Predation is a major aspect affecting animal survival and reproductive success in the wild. Anti-predator behaviours greatly vary between species but also among individuals of the same species. Differences within a species may be derived from differences in personalities. Several bird species, including the great tit, have evolved a specific vocal response towards a threatening situation – the hissing call – but not all individuals elicit hissing. I investigated the hissing behaviour of female great tits by presenting a great spotted woodpecker decoy – a species that is a common nest-predator of cavity-nesting birds. I compared breeding characteristics, the number of nests depredated by predators, nest-site preferences, and differences in the genotype over four years. According to my results, the response type of female great tits varied within the population, but the individual behavioural type remained relatively consistent in time. Start of egg-laying or clutch size did not predict whether the female hissed or not, but birds that did not hiss raised more fledglings. Hatching success did not differ between hissing and non-hissing birds. Hissing females preferred to nest further away from conspecifics and were more likely found in a coniferous than in a deciduous forest. Nest depredation rate was not related to the propensity of hissing birds. Taken together, whether a female hisses or not may depend on the female’s personality and may be regarded as a personality trait. The same as females differ in their personalities, they differ in the way they interact with conspecifics or predators, and they may even differ in their parental abilities. As natural selection has maintained different behavioural types within the population, it is likely that the success of the different behavioural types may be found in differences in survival or breeding success.

The defence can be also followed in Zoom: https://ut-ee.zoom.us/j/97583801280?pwd=MDZaOW5sWFVSdXcvUE5UeGt1NkRrQT09 (Meeting ID:975 8380 1280, Passcode:061241).